Minutes of the 4 October 2018 Meeting

Minutes of meeting held at NHS Sports & Social Club on 4th Oct 18
With 23 members and guests in attendance.

A moments silence was observed for ex-committee member and chair chairman John McCarthy.
Apologies were received from Mssrs Milburn; Smith; Andy Kaye; Butcher; Blakey; Shiers; McEvoy;
Thornton and Bradbury.
Dinner was set for Friday 17th May. This was due to Cup Final being played next day. Menus and
prices TBA.
Membership was now due. Be aware you are not covered by RA insurances.
Liam Slack our guest and sports psychologist gave an outline of his career after his footballing
career hit the buffers at an early age being released as not good enough. Went to St Johns and got a
PHd in sports psychology. Is very passionate about his topic and now covers from premiere down to
national north/south. Discussed a few topics then had a group discussion. Main things to look for
are Think-Feel-Act; Mental toughness; Strength. Also touched on VAR.
Also had talks with Rugby and Cricket.

There being no more business meeting closed at 9.25
Ian Hotchkies

John McCarthy

York RA are saddened to announce the passing of John McCarthy. John was Chairman of York RA between 1982 and 1983 and will be remembered fondly by his contemporaries.

Our thoughts are with John’s loved ones at this sad time.

John’s funeral will be at 1pm on Monday 8 October, at York Crematorium.

Meetings 2018-19

The Committee and in particular the Secretary has been busy during the Summer trying to put together a range of events for the season ahead

Speakers include Liam Slack, Craig Pawson and Mike Riley from the PGMOL

Usual venue of York Hospital Sports Club on 1st Thursday of the month at 1930 hrs


The list to date is:

6 Sept – Trevor Massey, Ex-PGMOL and Stockport RA President

4 Oct – Liam Slack, Phsychologist PGMOL

1 Nov – tbc

6 Dec – Annual Quiz and Buffett

2019

3 Jan – Craig Pawson, PGMOL Referee

7 Feb – NRCFA tbc

7 March – Mike Riley, PGMOL

4 April – Andy Atkinson, Radio York

27 April – Annual Dinner (Marriott) prov.

2 May – AGM


Videos & Articles from Mal Davies – 24 August 2018

DERMOT GALLAGHER discusses incidents from last weekend
 
BOBBY MADLEY : Premier League referee quits
 
Also at: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-6088041/Bobby-Madley-moves-Norway-exit-Premier-League-referee.html
 
PREMIER LEAGUE : Why VAR is not being used this season
 
How the VAR was born and used in the World Cup
 
AHMET GUVENER : A comprehensive assessment of officiating in the World Cup in Russia
 
GABRIELE MARCOTTI talks to Pierluigi Collina about officiating in the World Cup
 
THE REFEREES’ ASSOCIATION – Development weekend 9/10th June
 
MANAGERS to receive red and yellow cards for misconduct
 
MATCH-FIXING : Inside the secret fight against match-fixing in football
 
PAUL REJER : Discusses Dissent
 
CONCACAF : Seitz hails commitment to development of female referees
 
FIRST MUSLIM WOMAN REFEREE
 
FIRST TRANSGENDER REFEREE : The world’s first transgender ref makes her debut
 
FAN acts as AR

NRCFA Referee Courses: September & October 2018

I am delighted to confirm that we have arranged 4 FA Referee Courses to take place from September 2018 as follows:
 
CO3/18 – Richmond School, Richmond DL10 7BQ
Commences on Monday, 03 September 2018 – 6pm – 9.30pm
 
CO4/18 – Acklam Green Centre, Middlesbrough TS5 4JS 
Commences on Monday, 17 September 2018 – 6pm – 9.30pm
 
CO5/18 – Poppleton Football Club, York YO26 6LY
Commences on Monday, 01 October 2018 – 6pm – 9.30pm
 
CO6/18 – Scarborough Sixth Form College, Scarborough YO12 5LF
Commences on Monday, 15 October 2018 – 6pm – 9.30pm
 
We have 24 places available on each course (96 places in total) and have received a very high demand of interest in our FA Referee Courses.  Please note that the courses will be on a first come, first served basis and we strongly advise making a booking sooner rather than later as we have released the courses on our social media platforms also.
 
The cost of our FA Referee Courses are £130.00 per candidate with a minimum age of 14 required in order to book a place.   The course format for all 4 courses is as follows:
 
Ø  Classroom Introduction Workshop (Unit 1): 6pm – 9.30pm
 
Ø  Safeguarding Children Workshop (For those Candidates 16 Years of age +)  For those Candidates 14 & 15 Years of age, an online learning platform will be issued & FA CRC Verification Workshop: 6pm – 9.30pm
 
Ø  E -Learning will be assigned at the Unit 1 Workshop for Candidates to complete remotely ahead of the Practical Workshop (Units 2-4):  3 Weeks to complete
 
Ø  Full Referee Development Practical Day (Units 2-4): 9am – 5pm
 
Ø  Officiate 5 Games @ 11v11 or 9v9 within local Grassroots Football (Unit 5):  8 Weeks to complete  (Scarborough Course have 15 weeks due to winter months)
 
Ø  Final Assessment / Theory Examination (Unit 6):  6pm – 9.30pm
 
Please click on the above specific links to view further information, or use the below link to view all course available on our main Refereeing section of the website:
 
 
We also have some promotional videos about our NRCFA Referee Courses that you may find beneficial:
 
 

New Reporting procedure for Red Cards

With effect from the start of 2018-19 season the FA has announced a change to reporting for players being sent off

The system is basically the same as it is for yellow cards *(ie no details); this will make reporting so much easier for referees.

The notice from the FA is as follows:

“Currently Referees across the game at all levels when dismissing a player from the field of play are required to write a detailed report of the offence when reporting the dismissal.

The purpose of this report is largely historic and relates to when Players were able to appeal a dismissal and attend a Personal hearing to challenge the report. The move at grassroots level from term based discipline to match based discipline prevented personal hearings for red card offences and was replaced with the wrongful dismissal process.

The requirement to report the detail of the dismissal is not necessary for the Wrongful Dismissal process that now applies at all levels of the game and in fact contributes to confusion as to the purpose of that process.

The ability to claim a Wrongful Dismissal applies where a Club can demonstrate that the decision to send off a player for the offence committed was obviously wrong.

Clubs often concentrate their submissions on perceived errors in the detail of the report rather than whether the decision to send off for the offence was or was not correct. The onus is on the Club to show that the referee was obviously wrong in the dismissal offence and where they cannot satisfy that burden any claim should fail. It has therefore been agreed to amend the reporting process with effect from the start of the 2018/19 season to operate the same as reporting yellow card offences. This change will apply at all levels of the game.

Therefore the referee is only required to report the red card offences as laid out in the laws of the game as follows:

S1. Serious Foul Play

S2. Violent Conduct

S3. Spits at an Opponent or any other person

S4. Denying the opposing player an obvious goal scoring opportunity by deliberately handling the ball

S5. Denies the opposing player an obvious goal scoring opportunity by an offence punishable by a free kick or penalty kick

S6. Uses Offensive, insulting or abusive language

S7. Receives a second caution in the same match (This offence also requires the referee to report the caution offence for each caution)

Offences of S2 – Violent conduct will be categorised further with the following categories:

S2 – Violent Conduct – Head to Head contact

S2 – Violent Conduct – Elbowing

S2 – Violent Conduct – Kicking

S2 – Violent Conduct – Stamping

S2 – Violent Conduct – Striking

S2 – Violent Conduct – Biting

S2 – Violent Conduct – Other Unspecified Behaviour*

(* A free text field to capture other Unspecified Behaviour will be available if this option is selected).

There will be no requirement to write any further details for dismissals. This will save the referees time in reporting and avoid supplying unnecessary detail surrounding the offence.

It should be noted that both MOAS and WGS Portal are being amended to permit this change.

Extraordinary Reports
“Referees will still be required to write details surrounding extraordinary incidents in the following circumstances.
a. Where the dismissal offence has a more serious impact than the dismissal itself, the referee will be required to submit the dismissal offence as normal and then add a supplementary extraordinary report clarifying why the dismissal was exceptional. Such examples would be where the offence committed included an aggravated breach such as discriminatory language or behaviour (homophobic, sexist or reference to race/colour/religion/ethnicity etc.) or here there was a serious injury caused by the act of violent conduct.

b. Where further misconduct happened following the dismissal such as the player refusing to leave the field of play or committed other further acts of misconduct following the dismissal.

c. Where the offences committed were by non-playing staff or spectators.””

Mark Ives

Head of Judicial Services                                                                                                                                          June 2018

Len Randall

A few days ago The RA was notified of the sad news of Len Randall passing away, on a personal note Len provided a great source of wisdom to me following the Board of Inquiry in 2012, I am very grateful to Ian Davies for producing the obituary below.

LEN RANDALL

Len Randall joined the Referees’ Association in 1985 and, in a distinguished career covering many decades, he held office at National, County and local level. On 28th May 2018, upon Len’s death, the Referees’ Association lost a great ambassador, stalwart, friend and supporter. His legacy will form part of the history of the Referees’ Association.

Len will be remembered as a dedicated, committed, enthusiastic and, above all, respected member of the Referees’ Association. He was an honourable gentleman who believed in integrity and principles and this ethos formed an important part of his life. These attributes accurately reflect Len’s character and personality.

Len was a founder member of the RA Board upon its inception in 2004 and he would hold office as RA Chairman and RA Treasurer. Len was RA Chairman when the new format of the RA Conference weekend was established in 2005 at the Southport Conference. The foundations of the current Development Weekend were laid under his stewardship and the emphasis moved towards the provision of training for and development of referees. The Southport Conference will always be remembered as a catalyst for change and have a special place in the history of the Referees’ Association.

Len will be remembered for all the work he did behind the scenes at national level and the varied tasks included creating membership databases, preparation of AGM / Conference papers, printing tickets, Head Office administration to mention just a few for which he never expected any accolade. Len believed it was his duty to help and make a positive contribution.

Len’s efforts were not limited to supporting the national body and he also made important contributions at County and Local level. Len held office at Middlesex County RA as both Secretary and Treasurer and he was latterly the Chiltern District Referees’ Society delegate to Berks and Bucks County RA. He served in this role with distinction and only relinquished this post in the last few months.

Len had been a full member of Chiltern District Referees’ Society since 2008 and during the intervening decade he had made a significant contribution to the society. The esteem in which he was held by his local society is shown by the fact that he was twice the recipient of the Horace Freeman Memorial Award and he was the current holder. The award recognised the outstanding contribution he had made to the society. Len’s wealth of knowledge and inspiration would have a positive impact upon all members.

Len’s was a great believer in governance and rules and his undoubted abilities excelled in the reorganisation and restructuring process of the National Referees’ Association. Len was an influential member of the Constitutional Review Committee which ultimately resulted in the current Referees’ Association Constitution. It is no surprise that Len was the architect for new rules for his local society and County RA.

It was Len’s passion for proper procedural requirements that led him to take the lead in instigating the complete overhaul of the Referees’ Association Benevolent Fund Deed of Trust in order to ensure that the trustees acted in accordance within the law and the requirements of the Charity Commission. He also drafted a Memorandum of Procedures to be followed by the Benevolent Fund Trustees when considering an application for assistance from the Benevolent Fund. His guidance and advice would be valued by all fellow Trustees.

Len felt it was important to keep open lines of communication with members and societies. In order to achieve this goal Len was an avid contributor to the Chiltern Referee Magazine and his articles were always balanced and informative. He had also acted as editor of the RA Newsletter distributed nationally.

Len’s contribution to the Referees’ Association cannot be under-estimated and he undoubtedly exemplified the RA motto of “service before self”.

Len’s funeral service will be held on Wednesday 13th June 2018 at 11am at Breakspear Crematorium, Breakspear Road, Ruislip HA4 7SJ.

Videos & Articles from Mal Davies – Fri 18 May 2018

DERMOT GALLAGHER discusses the best and worst referee calls in 2017/18 EPL season
 
TWO SG REFEREES RETIRE
 
From prison to Premier League
 
GREATEST FA CUP COMEBACKS
 
THE FAA issue written reasons for Otis Khan’s extended suspension from 3 to 5 matches
 
MARK CLATTENBURG to referee Cascadia’s opener and the Final
  
PAUL REJER : Play of the Week 11 – discusses Unsporting Behaviour and The Referee (Law 5)
 
GARY WILLARD : Referees at Premier Skills very keen on learning
 
16-GAME BAN for pushing assistant referee
 
BRAZIL : Should professional referees be regulated?
 
EGYPT : New FIFA referees’ 2018 training course
 
ETHIOPIA : Referee attacked unconvinced by assurances
 
FIJI : Seven-match ban to player for comments to white referee
 
GREECE : Spanish referee appointed for Cup Final but…….
……the Final ends in chaos
 
NEW ZEALAND : The referee who also adjudicated in the classroom

2018 Secretary’s Report

Secretary’s Report 3rd May 2018

It has been a bad year with members passing away, with life member Don Thorpe and ex members John Fowler; Kevin Sweeting; and Keith Hatfield.

Overall it has been a good season for us with membership up, partly due to the newly qualified members getting a year with no payments.

Attendances averaged at 25 with highest 36 for Neil Swarbrick  to 19 in September.  Once again we had some excellent guests including Neil Swarbrick; Mark Haywood; and Guy Mowbray. Unfortunately Trevor Massey’s wife took ill at the last minute, but he has rescheduled for next season. Thanks to all who assisted with the evenings; Alan Kay; Tony Thornton; Sam Bayley.

One the social side we had Tony’s Quiz; Lol Cussons evening and our dinner. All enjoyable events but sadly numbers for the Lol Cussons and Dinner are falling. Congratulations to all who received awards at the two events.

Congratulations to all who gained promotions and final appointments, they are rewards for your endeavours over the season.

Thanks to all who helped out with raffles and committee throughout.

Ian Hotchkies

Minutes of the 3 May 2018 Meeting

Minutes of meeting held after AGM

With 11 members in attendance

At NHS Club on 3rd May 2018

The chairman welcomed all to a very depleted meeting.

Apols were received from Mssrs Rich; McEvoy; Luff; P Hartley; Blakey; Burke; Thornton.

Congratutations were given  James Unwin and Connor Ledgeway on their promotions to levels 3  and 4. Alan Kaye gave them both some sound advice for the coming season.

Minutes last meeting,  no matters arising.

Dinner, discussion on; main problem was lack of quantity with the salmon course and lack of veg. Take on board for next event. Was discussion on how to attract younger members to the event.

Problem Corner, Chris Harris (new ref) went through his abandonment of a match due to injury and helicopter being called in. He had coped very well and hopefully some good advice given during the discussion.

Speakers , discussion on speakers and format for next season.

Meeting closed at 9.05

Ian Hotchkies